Before deciding to visit A&E

Pre arrival  Outside the hospital  Entrance area  Reception space  Waiting  Triage  Patient bays  Staff base

If people think they need medical attention or advice, they have to decide whether they go to their GP, to A&E or to another healthcare service.

Their decision about which service they should go to, and when, can be influenced by a number of factors, including how urgently they need attention, the nature of their problem or how close they are to the location of a certain healthcare provider. However, many people’s default choice is to visit A&E and this can result in overcrowding and longer waiting times that can leave visitors feeling stressed, which may make them more likely to behave aggressively.

By working with designers, healthcare providers can share the information people need in order to decide which is the most appropriate healthcare service for them to access, and they can help manage expectations about a visit to A&E by providing details on waiting times and services provided.

Information design

NHS Direct has been designed to help people make an informed decision and then find out where they can find their nearest relevant healthcare provider. It acts as a fast-track system to direct minor-injuries patients to the most suitable treatment for them. It is delivered online, but crucially also has a telephone hotline which is open 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.

NHS Direct offers national advice services, but how could designers help you deliver information that is relevant to local people?

The ChooseWell campaign, created by Knowsley Primary Care Trust (PCT) in partnership with NHS Direct, but now supported across the UK, aims to reduce the burden on all in-demand NHS services by helping people to associate the severity of their symptoms with a particular NHS service:

  • A&E or 999 — for critical or life-threatening situations
  • NHS Walk-in Centre — for treatment of minor illnesses or injuries, without an appointment
  • GP — for medical advice, examinations and prescriptions for illnesses you just can’t shake off
  • Pharmacist — for advice on common winter illnesses, and the best medicines to treat them
  • NHS Direct — for absolutely any health questions, around the clock, and to find local services
  • Self-care — for treatment of minor winter illnesses, by combining a well stocked medicine cabinet with plenty of rest  

A set of campaign resources has been designed to help spread the message and videos are a key part of the campaign:

Local NHS Trusts, such as NHS North West, have created their own viral videos to spread the message about when to go to A&E.

 

The United Lincolnshire Hospitals NHS Trust has recognised that visitors understanding of current demand levels in A&E will impact upon their overall satisfaction with the service. It designed a new way for its A&E departments to communicate with patients before they arrive at A&E. Webcams positioned in the waiting areas stream real-time information onto the Trust website, so potential can check out how busy the departments are before deciding to visit. [Reference: United Lincolnshire Hospitals NHS Trust, Live waiting times, 2010]

By working with designers on a new phone service, smartphone app or website feed, how could you provide information on current waiting times and demand levels in your A&E department, in order to help patients are able to make a more informed decision on which department to attend and when?

 

Service design

“The many causes of overcrowding have had a negative effect on physician productivity. Emergency physicians have attempted to fill in the gaps, as they must stretch their ability to see many patients at the same time. At a certain limit of patients, productivity declines and patient care is compromised.” [Reference: Derlet and Richards, 2000].

Often, A&E is not the only place patients can receive the diagnosis, advice and treatment they require. NHS Direct can help visitors decide to use alternative treatment facilities that are available, but this advice is not necessarily tailored to local situations. So, NHS Bristol launched its own iPhone app to provide local patients with information on local health services and how they could access them. The app gives GPS directions and sends reminders about GP appointments in a bid to cut down on the number – and cost – of missed meetings. [Reference: www.managementinpractice.com]

How could you work with designers to develop a new system that enables visitors to determine the correct place for them to receive care before they default to visiting A&E?

 

Read on

Use the links below to find out more about the triggers of violence and aggression at other stages of the patient's journey through A&E and how procuring design can help make A&E safer for staff and patients

A&E entrance illustration

Entrance area

By working with designers, A&E managers can create a welcoming and easy to use entrance space that delivers a positive first impression and sets the tone for the rest of the A&E experience

A&E waiting area illustration

Waiting

Waiting areas can be designed to work as a useful tool to reinforce a positive sense of progression through the treatment system

Perpetrators of violence and aggression

 

Frustrated illustration

 

Frustrated

For the majority of attenders to A&E, the goal is simple: to receive the attention they need, as quickly as possible. People can easily be frustrated by waiting.

 

Triggers of violence and aggression

 

Perceived inefficiency

 

From a patient’s perspective it can sometimes feel as if staff in A&E environments are disorganised and lacking focus.

 

Find out more about this and other triggers of violence and aggression in A&E

 

QOF

 

Effective from 1 April 2012, NHS Employers and the General Practitioners Committee (GPC) have agreed a number of changes to the quality and outcomes framework (QOF) including the introduction of three new organisational indicators for improving Quality and Productivity which focus on accident and emergency attendances.


 
GP Practices will have to undertake a review of their patients' A&E attendances by August 2012.

 

"The review will include consideration of whether access to clinicians in the practice is appropriate, in light of the patterns on accident and emergency attendance."

 

In addition, practices must exchange data to conduct external peer reviews, agree an action plan with the Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) and implement it before April 2013.

 

The review may include proposals to improve access to the practice or plans to redesign services or commission new ones.

 


 

Perpetrator characteristics

Six sets of perpetrator characteristics that highlight the diversity of people who become violent and aggressive in A&E.

Find out more